And as many of us have done or might be capable of doing. In the courtroom, he withheld moral witness and remained silent, as she did, as most Germans did. He seeks understanding for himself, although perhaps he doesn't realize that. But she thinks he seeks understanding for Hanna. The enormity of her sin far outweighs his, but they are both guilty of allowing harm because they reject the choice to do good.Īt the film's end, Michael encounters a Jewish woman in New York ( Lena Olin), who eviscerates him with her moral outrage. She was isolated and secretive after the war, he became so after the trial. He has never recovered from the wound he received from Hanna, nor from the one he inflicted on himself eight years after. We see him after a night with a woman, treating her with remote politeness. The adult Michael has sentenced himself to a lonely, isolated existence. His discovery does not excuse her unforgivable guilt. Something during this trial suddenly makes another of her secrets clear to him and might help explain why she became a prison guard.
Eight years later, as a law student, he enters a courtroom and discovers Hanna in a group of Nazi prison guards being tried for murder. His unformed ego is unprepared for this blow. Michael finds her apartment deserted, with no hint or warning. Sex afterwards." The director, Stephen Daldry, portrays them with a great deal of nudity and sensuality, which is correct, because for those hours, in that place, they are about nothing else. What does she get from their affair? Sex, certainly, but it seems more important that he read aloud to her: "Reading first. He is swept away by the discovery of his own sexuality. Hanna makes little pretense of genuinely loving Michael, who she calls "kid," and although Michael has a helpless crush on Hanna, it should not be confused with love. This day, and all their days together, will be obsessed with sex. The story begins with the cold, withdrawn Michael in middle age (Fiennes), and moves back to the late 1950s on a day when young Michael is found sick and feverish in the street and taken back to Hanna's apartment to be cared for. It is powerfully, if sometimes confusingly, told in a flashback framework and powerfully acted by Winslet and Kross, with Ralph Fiennes coldly enigmatic as the elder Michael.
That such things are wrong is beside the point they happen, and the story is about how it connected with her earlier life and his later one. The film centers on a sexual relationship between Hanna ( Kate Winslet), a woman in her mid-30s, and Michael (David Kross), a boy of 15.
0 kommentar(er)
